Avoid Candidates Can That Hurt Your Hiring Process

How you treat the job seekers you don’t hire could affect your chances of finding the best employees in the future, new research finds.

A study from CareerArc, an HR technology provider, and Future Workplace, revealed that 60 percent of job seekers have had a poor candidate experience, and of those, 72 percent have shared that negative experience online on an employer review site, on a social networking site, or directly with a colleague or friend.

“Companies need to start humanizing their candidate experience because job seekers can easily share their negative experiences online and decide never to apply to that company again,” Dan Schawbel, research director at Future Workplace, said in a statement. “Treat your candidates like you would your employees or customers because they have the power to refer strong candidates even if they don’t get hired.”

“This survey reveals a critical blind spot employers have when it comes to candidate experience, and that is the experience of the declined candidate,” said Robin Richards, CEO of CareerArc. “In this tightening labor market, companies can no longer afford to overlook this vocal majority of applicants who didn’t get the job, but simply expect to be acknowledged.”

Despite nearly all employers seeing the value of keeping in touch with declined candidates, less than half actually do so. Those surveyed said re-engaging with job seekers who weren’t hired is a good opportunity for their company to build their talent community and protect their employer brand.

The technology many employers are using as part of the hiring process is also leaving job seekers with a poor impression. With nearly 40 percent of employers relying on technology that pre-screens or preselects candidates based on the data they’ve submitted, 85 percent of job seekers doubt that a human ever even reviewed their resume when they don’t hear back.

Although applicant-screening technology might save employers time during the hiring process, it also might not be revealing the best candidates. More than 60 percent of the employers surveyed admitted that these types of programs could be overlooking qualified candidates.

The problem for many businesses is that they have no idea whether or not they are providing a good experience for job seekers. Only 25 percent of employers regularly request feedback directly from candidates on their experience, with 78 percent of job seekers saying they’ve never been asked to give feedback on the process.

The good news is that many employers plan to work on improving their hiring process. The study discovered that 70 percent of companies have invested, or plan to invest, more resources in improving the candidate experience in the next year.

“This presents a tremendous opportunity for employers who recognize the need to reframe the rejection process, improve on candidate care, and prioritize the needs of all applicants today so they return to reapply tomorrow,” Richards said.